🔗 Share this article

At least eleven jurisdictions and a pair of regions have agreed to a new demand from the federal government to remove references of gender identity and the existence of trans and non-binary people from a national sex education initiative, officials confirmed.

The administration established a recent cutoff for removing these mentions, warning the loss of substantial government funding. Nearly all of the complying states have Republican-controlled lawmaking bodies and mostly Republican state leaders.

Court Battles and Funding Conflicts

Sixteen other states and the nation's capital have filed a lawsuit challenging the administration's demand, claiming it infringes on Congressional authority, which established the $75 million sexual health initiative, known as the Personal Responsibility Education Program (Prep).

All states participating in the legal challenge are led by Democrat state executives.

In a late Monday judicial ruling, a U.S. judge blocked the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), which oversees Prep, from withholding financial support to the suing jurisdictions if they refuse to comply.

“The agency does not demonstrate that the new grant conditions are reasonable, let alone offer any valid reason, other than pretext, for its actions,” stated Ann Aiken, a federal jurist in Oregon. “The department offers no proof that it made factual findings or considered the statutory objectives.”

Initiative Aims and Government Scrutiny

The program aims to inform adolescents on healthy relationships and how to avoid pregnancy and the transmission of sexually transmitted infections.

In April, the federal government required all jurisdictions receiving Prep funds to submit a version of their curriculum to HHS and its agency, the ACF office, for a health content assessment.

By late summer, the government sent letters to 46 states and territories, informing them that, during the review, it had found “material in the educational programs that deviate from the scope of the program's legal framework.”

Specifically, the administration claimed it had uncovered evidence of “gender-related concepts,” a term often used by conservative factions to describe the notion that identity is a changeable social construct and that transgender individuals exist.

Notable Cases of Required Alterations

The administration instructed Illinois to drop a lesson that said: “Adolescents may identify in ways that differ from their biological sex.”

It instructed another state to eliminate a line from a middle school lesson that stated: “People of all sexual orientations and gender identities need to know how to prevent pregnancy and STDs.”

Moreover, health instructors in numerous states could no longer be told to “show tolerance and understanding for all participants, irrespective of personal characteristics, including ethnicity, cultural background, religion, social class, orientation or identity,” according to the letters sent to states.

Official Statements and Jurisdictional Reactions

“Accountability is coming,” declared Andrew Gradison, acting assistant secretary of the Administration for Children and Families, in a statement. “Government money will not be used to poison the minds of the next generation or promote harmful political doctrines.”

Several jurisdictions and regions confirmed they would remove the references or had completed the process. These include Alaska, Georgia, Iowa, Kentucky, Mississippi, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, West Virginia and Wyoming, as well as the two territories.

Another pair of jurisdictions, Alabama and South Dakota, reported their educational programs never included the terminology referenced in the government's notices.

Effects on Adolescents and Psychological Well-being

Together, these jurisdictions are inhabited by more than 120k trans people aged 13 to 17, based on estimates from a university department.

“When the aim is to help adolescents and give them a safe space, I’m not sure why we are targeting the most vulnerable youth in the population,” commented Cindi Huss, who heads Rise that offers health instruction in Tennessee.

“When the government says that there’s something incorrect about you and the educators aren’t allowed to tell you things or they have to out you to your parents – when you know that that’s not safe – that’s horrible for mental health.”

Almost 50% of trans and non-binary youth seriously considered suicide in the past year, based on a recent study from a mental health organization. School support for these youths is associated with reduced numbers of self-harm attempts, the group found.

Earlier Incidents and Ongoing Disputes

Earlier this year, the Trump administration ordered California to cut mentions to gender identity from its Prep curriculum.

When the jurisdiction refused, the administration revoked its funding, cutting approximately $12m in federal funding and halting health initiatives in educational institutions, juvenile detention facilities and care facilities.

The California health department is appealing the withdrawal. So far, it has been unsuccessful in make up for the withdrawn money.

The government has also informed educators who receive funding from additional national programs, the $50 million Sexual Risk Avoidance Education (SRAE) and the $101 million TPPP initiative, that they cannot teach about “gender-related concepts.”

An early October judicial ruling blocked the government from changing one program, while the latest ruling prohibits it from changing SRAE in the suing jurisdictions that sued over the initiative.

The ACF office did not immediately respond to a inquiry.